It’s time to call out Sean Hross and his weird theories he’s spreading and hating the Swiss people all over the internet.
It’s time to call out Sean Hross and his weird theories he’s spreading and hating the Swiss people all over the internet.
Thesis: http://blog.templarhistory.com/2010/03/did-the-templars-form-switzerland/
Answers:
First answer.
Wow. I’m not a historian, so, happy to be corrected, but my instinct on this one is to call bullshit. Very loudly.
- Yes, their decline was roughly, plus or minus a few decades around the time Switzerland formed. Honestly, that doesn’t mean much.
- Switzerland is East of France? WEll, at the time, East of France was the Empire. Why Switzerland, especially? It’s just one part of the Empire
- Mysterious tales of white knights? First of all, sources? I’ve certainly never heard any. Also, why mysterious? Wouldn’t people recognize them?
- Sure, they were big on banking. You know who wasn’t? THe early Swiss. Early Switzerland was poor. It took centuries for Switzerland to become a banking country.
- We don’t know our history? Yeah, no. I mean, sure, there are parts we don’t know in detail. That’s history. There’s a few national myths, like Wilhelm Tell. Everyone has those. But most of it is known.
- The templar cross is on the flags of the Swiss cantons? Yeah, no. THese are the flags of the original three cantons:
Second Answer.
Agreeing with the other answers here, I would have made similar points, just one more:
Third Answer.
The reference given is pure bullshit – a historian who starts by saying “read my book” is to be listened to only with precaution.
- Help each other against arsonists
- Control the northern reaches of the Gotthard Pass
- Not create a country!
Source
Next question:
Is it true that modern Switzerland has roots of Knights Templar who escaped from 1307 arrests?
It is very unlikely. The original Swiss confederation in the 13th century was made up of people from difficult to access mountain valleys within the Holy Roman Empire. They had a status that made them directly accountable to the emperor but were threatened by Habsburg “expansionism” within the empire. Their objective was to protect themselves against the Habsburg but also to ensure the peaceful management of the important trade routes through the Alps.
Although these regions are easy to access today both by train and by car, it doesn’t require much imagination to realise just how wild the place must have been before tunnels and bridges were built to make the Gotthard pass more accessible:
Even then it was rather scary in the best of weathers:
It is only round the nineteenth and twentieth centuries that it was made secure. Today the region is a paradise for hikers. So long as the weather is good!
It was a region inhabited by mountain farmers who made some money providing shelter to the merchants crossing the Alps with their wares.
Switzerland grew progressively over the centuries to become the country that we know today. It was to take hundreds of years before it became a rich country. In fact that happened in the last hundred to a hundred and fifty years with the rise of tourism, banking and the service industries that are the basis of the modern economy.
To earn money many Swiss worked as mercenaries in foreign armies including the Pope’s. This probably made them a well trained force with experience of real fighting. They would also have known the ground well and the very remoteness and wildness of the region would have made them a tough proposition to conquer!
There is no historical evidence of any Templar influence in the early history of Switzerland and no particular reason for them to want to go to a small region withing the Holy Roman Empire which had neither fortune, nor particular interest at the time.
Next question.
Are Swiss the Templar Knights?
First answer.
No. The Templars were suppressed as an Order throughout Latin Christendom in 1312. Surviving brethren were farmed out to other orders, usually the Hospitallers. In Portugal, the brethren were formed into a new order, the Order of Christ.
Second answer.
Banking secrecy only exists since 1934.
Next
Why does Switzerland have the Knights Templar cross as their flag?
First answer.
Thanks for asking me Ross.
Second answer.
Are you kidding me? Are you blind sighted?
- The Swiss cross is white, the KT cross is red,
- The Swiss cross is rectangular, the KT cross is shaped.